Grundvattentäkter är essentiella inslag i vårt samhälle. Mark- och miljööverdomstolen (MÖD) meddelade nyligen dom i två intressanta mål om dispens för att installera bergvärme inom ett vattenskyddsområde i Uppsala. Bakgrunden till avgörandena är nästan identiska, men avviker något i omständigheterna.
Skyddsföreskrifter stoppade bergvärmeborrning
Juridikanalys I två olika fall har Miljööverdomstolen (MÖD) nekat tillstånd till bergvärmeborrning i vattenskyddsområde. Jurist John Woivalin, rådgivare och redaktör på JP Miljönet, analyserar domarna.

MÖD stoppade bergvärmeborrning i två fall. Foto: StockAdobe
Någonting är fel
Du är inloggad som prenumerant hos förlaget Pauser Media, men nånting är fel. På din profilsida ser du vilka av våra produkter som du har tillgång till. Skulle uppgifterna inte stämma på din profilsida – vänligen kontakta vår kundtjänst.
Miljö & Utveckling premium
Läs vidare – starta din prenumeration
- Magasinet Miljö & Utveckling - 6 nummer per år
- Full tillgång till allt digitalt material
Redan prenumerant? Logga in och läs vidare.

I mål M 14036-20 avsåg ett bolag att bygga ett antal flerbostadshus och anlägga en bergvärmeanläggning med borrhål i Ultuna. Bolaget ville få till 20 borrhål för installationen. I mål M 7756-20 avsåg ett annat bolag att vidta snarlika åtgärder, då bolaget ville borra bergvärme i Valsätra. I detta mål försökte bolaget få till 219 borrhål för fyra fristående bergvärmesystem.
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


